The independents that win in 2027 will win where networks and AI can't replicate: their people, their culture and the trust they build with clients, backed by the commercial discipline and an Indie pride.
The conditions for growth are seemingly returning.The UK economy is up 2% on last year, with services growing 0.9% in Q3, and the IPA Bellwether shows marketing budgets rising at their fastest rate in two years. Hiring is back too: in September, permanent placements rose for the first time in nearly four years. Talent is moving and when people move, ideas, relationships and budgets move with them.
However, a recovering market is not the same as a stable one – and is still volatile. Yesterday, we sat down with founders and leaders from Entourage, Pablo, Piqniq, The Alliance of Independent Agencies and Journey HR to hear what's working for them right now, where they see the industry heading, and how they believe independents can win in 2027.
AI hasn't changed what great indies look for in people - they're still hiring creative, curious, ambitious and kind people who are capable of original thought. What AI has done is make some skills far more valuable. The most sought-after in 2027 will be critical thinking, followed closely by strong client relationship skills, because the human side of the work matters more than ever.
“Anyone can use AI, but if you've gotthe power of critical thinking, it becomes a superpower. If it's mediocre, it just turns out to be slop.” - Terry, The Alliance
The biggest risk is a quiet one, many agencies have stopped hiring juniors, opening up a succession gap that will be felt in a few years' time, even though the calibre of graduates available right now is exceptional precisely because so few are hiring them.
“If you remove the bottom rung from the ladder, then no one can climb it.” - Bee, Piqniq
Bee and the panel also had a warning; when juniors go straight to AI tools, they miss out on learning how and why things work, so they can't tell when the output is wrong,and weak work ends up in front of clients. One fix suggested is to ask your most senior people to document how they use AI on a real piece of work, so the team can see that a great result still takes an hour of skilled challenge. There was discussion around looking at every vacancy as a chance to rethink the role: should it evolve, adapt or change entirely, rather than simply being replaced like for like? Across the industry, the picture isn't fewer people, it's peopledoing different things.
The takeaway: keep hiring juniors, teach the fundamentals before the shortcuts,and make critical thinking an explicit part of how you hire and train.
Scale has long been the one advantage networks could count on, but that advantage is shrinking as independents team up with other specialist agencies to compete for bigger briefs, without giving up their independence. Clients are actively seeking out indies that collaborate, because they get hyper-focused expertise in every discipline rather than one-size-fits-all.
“They don't want to go to a network where they're getting several shades of vanilla. They want to have those experts actually working.” - Terry, The Alliance
The takeaway: collaboration only works with partners you trust, so choose them carefully. When it does work, it pays off: agencies collaborating today are winning work none of them would have won alone.
An indie's reputation starts with the quality of its work and the results it delivers for clients. Beyond that, the agencies that win rosters are famous for one specific thing, ironically agencies are often the worst at marketing themselves.
Owned platforms, such as an events series built up over a few years, can open doors to new clients and even raise an agency's value when it's acquired.
“No one else is going to do your PR. You have to do your own PR.” - Ben, Pablo
The takeaway: decide what you want to be famous for, build a platform you own to say it consistently, and tell the stories about how you treat your people, not just the work you make.
Sales is still a bit of a dirty word in agency culture, but plenty of indies have great work and great people and still struggle to grow. In Ross's experience at Entourage, the ones that have scaled over the last 20-odd years had one thing in common: they could sit in front of a client and sell. His rule of thumb for a healthy new business mix is a third from referrals, a third from inbound and a third from net new. Agencies that rely solely on referrals can struggle when those dry up.
“New business is like keeping weight off. Nobody sees the work that goes into it, but the moment you stop, it all comes undone. Ease off for a month, and you’ll feel the gap in your pipeline for the next three.” - Ross, Entourage
Timing also matters - The Alliance's July Commercial Pulse found, for the first time in the survey's history, that brand new clientshad overtaken existing ones as members' leading source of revenue, a sign that brands are starting to shop around again.
Thetakeaway: go after the big pitches, but don't overlook the small projects. A £5,000 to £30,000 project is too small for a network to bother with, farcheaper to win than a full pitch, and often the easiest way onto a roster. Once you're on, growth tends to follow quickly.
The fastest-growing indies are spending less time on decks and more time getting the right people in front of the client. Entourage writes around 80 new piecesof work a month, which would be impossible with full pitch decks, and this year it beat major networks without one.
“When was the last time you went to a doctor and they told you about all their qualifications and all the illnesses they've cured? They don't. They ask clever questions to diagnose the problem.” - Ross, Entourage
This will only become more important as clients grow weary of decks that have obviously been through an AI tool, putting a premium on genuine thinking and human chemistry in the room. Being selective helps as well - some indies have found that turning down a pitch for lack of capacity has led clients to come back and move the timeline to fit, and the strongest agencies now ask whether a client is the right partner for them just as hard as the client asks the reverse.
The takeaway: lead with questions rather than credentials, protect your best pitch people from burnout by building more than one pitch team, and rememberthat a confident no can be more persuasive than an exhausted yes.
Pricing is one of the biggest gaps between independents and the procurement teams they sell to. Procurement are trained, skilled negotiators, while many agency leaders have never really studied pricing, and that imbalance shows up directly in their margins.
“Procurement are trained at what they doand very skilled at it, and it's your job as the seller, not their job as the buyer, to set the price and protect your margins.” - Ross, Entourage
The panel was clear: never price on hours, because that's a game procurement will always win,and price on outputs and value instead. Ross's advice was to treat pricing as a skill worth learning, and he recommended following pricing strategist Tim Williams and Tom Kennard, formerly chief procurement officer at WPP. Piqniq sees the client side of the same coin: long-standing clients stay because they feel like partners, not because they're billed for every moment of thinking.
The takeaway: treat pricing as a skill to build, not a number to defend, and aim for three to six months' cash in the bank, which is only possible when you stop quietly working for free.
Not every indieis riding the upturn. Agencies working with large global clients are dealing with constant reorganisations, and some have lost clients overnight to events entirely outside their control. The ones that come through it have built resilience into how they work.
That means building relationships with more than one person in every account, keeping the pipeline moving even when the team is busy, and spreading revenue across sectors. It also means putting people processes in place before you need them.
“It's about how you can innovate within the problem, and whether there's someone else for whom it might be a solution or an opportunity.” - Bee, Piqniq
The takeaway: don't go it alone. Bring in a non-exec, a mentor or a peer who has been through tough times before, because running an independent can be lonely, and an outside perspective helps you see the wood for the trees when it matters most.
Collaboration,challenging the status quo and the same fundamentals that have always worked, aligning to clients' challenges, winning new work and motivating the team to deliver it, all came up as the defining traits of next year's winners. Underneath all of them sits the same human edge, and what turns that edge into growth is clarity of purpose.
“We sat in a room in 2017 and agreed we want to be the best creative agency in the world. Everything we do ladders to that, and if it doesn't ladder to that, we don't do it.” - Ben, Pablo
The indies that win in 2027 will know who they are, what they stand for and what they're worth.They'll know which clients they want and which pitches to walk away from, which skills they need and which hires don't share their values, and they'll hold that line when procurement pushes back or the market wobbles. Collaboration, sales, talent and reputation all matter enormously, but they work best in service of a business that knows exactly where it's going.
The market is turning and talent is on the move, which means the opportunity for independents is real, but it will go to the agencies that are clear enough to take it.
With thanks to Terry Martin (The Alliance of Independent Agencies), Ross Barker (Entourage), Ben Mascari (Pablo), Bee Pearson (Piqniq) and Sue Shaw (Journey HR).
----------------
Fancy another morning of brilliant conversations and connections?
The Alliance of Independent Agenciesis bringing together independent agency founders and senior leaders for Indie House on Thursday 26th November at The Ministry, London. Expect inspiring speakers, honest conversations about growth and leadership, and plenty of opportunities to connect with fellow independents.
Use code AIAINTRO26when booking to enjoy a special discounted rate.
Book your place at Indie House